A Comparison Guide: Fly Rods vs. Spinning Rods

A Comparison Guide: Fly Rods vs. Spinning Rods

Starting Out

Finding the right fishing rod is critical to maximizing your enjoyment when you are in the water. Therefore, following a comparison guide between fly rods vs. spinning rods helps you narrow down the best option for your needs.

Fly Rods



Stepping into a tranquil stream is an excellent way to get some rest and relaxation. Finding a rhythm with the gentle sounds of nature helps you zone out and feel at ease with the world.


No one likes doing the same thing continuously. The versatility of fly fishing is its most prominent benefit since you can use it in any body of water and catch virtually any fish. Mixing it up keeps things fresh, and each experience never feels the same.


Being concerned about the well-being of the fish you catch is a noble thing. Thus, fly fishing helps ease your heart because you can quickly catch fish and release them again. You can enjoy the thrill of catching fish without harming them.


Too Challenging

Starting with a fly rod is like a tee-ball player trying to get a hit off a high school pitcher: it can be overwhelming if you’re new to the game. The casting technique takes time to master, so it requires patience for anyone who is trying to learn or teach someone else.


The costs can add up if you are going to fly fish. Granted, the flies are less expensive, but the costs of the reel, backing, and waders add up.

Spin Rods


Wind Effects

Wind feels good when you are fishing on a hot, sunny day. However, it can be tough to cast, especially if you use a fly rod. If it’s really windy, use a traditional spin rod.


A spinning rod allows you to have complete control of your rod, correcting any errors you may encounter. The traditional spin rod is the best option for someone who is new to the angling game.


Casting in the exact spot you are aiming for is a big positive for a spinning rod. The heavier the lure, the farther it goes, landing in the precise location you have your eye on.


Troubling Water Conditions

If the water conditions are a bit murky, it can be challenging to fish with a spinning rod. Depending on where you are, tall grass, lily pads, and other obstacles may block your way.

Made for Heavier Fish

When you’re aiming to catch large fish, a spinning rod is the perfect tool. You wouldn’t want to cut paper with a pair of hedge clippers, which is essentially what you’re doing when you try to catch a bluegill with a spinning rod. It can be tricky to reel in some small catches on a rod built for heavier fish.

Every angler is different, so check out the American-made fly rods at Ed's Fly Shop to find what you need. All of our fly rods are made in the USA, so we're certain you'll find the perfect one!

Back to blogs